Homestuck Questions of the Day

Before posting on the forum, be sure to read the Forum Rules.
Saturday, August 2nd, 2025, 8:48 PMabout 2 months ago

Welcome to Homestuck Questions of the Day, where I ask a random questions related to Homestuck. This is inspired by my Fire Emblem Questions of the Day I do back in Serenes Forest Forums (I'm PerditaTacos there btw).

Don't ask why Geno hates Jade Harley.


Marth and Lyn from Fire Emblem in Super Smash Bros Ultimate


Lyndis
Thursday, August 28th, 2025, 5:29 PM21 days ago

It all takes place in a Discord server rather than Pesterchum and they VC and screen share all the time. Sburb would be a steam release game that everyone plays.

Bloodstuck Advert, Read on AO3

elegantSpinstress
Friday, August 29th, 2025, 2:53 PM20 days ago

Does Vriska enjoy the spa?

Don't ask why Geno hates Jade Harley.


Marth and Lyn from Fire Emblem in Super Smash Bros Ultimate


Lyndis
Friday, August 29th, 2025, 9:11 PM20 days ago

I think vriska would have mixed thoughts. I think she'd enjoy it if its a friend doing spa stuff with her, but I think she'd hate it if a stranger tried to do the same stuff (levels of trusts and all).



Saturday, August 30th, 2025, 0:16 AM20 days ago

the itsy bitsy spider

toweled up and hit the spa

out came the steam and tore her pores apart out crawled the spider a-hissing in her pain and the itsy bitsy spider went in the spa again

The success of a paradigm may not be for the reasons it claims (i.e. accurate description of the world). This is good.

"Malo" is fine
Saturday, August 30th, 2025, 0:17 AM20 days ago

Argh mobile formatting is really messing with me. Guess I should switch to desktop

The success of a paradigm may not be for the reasons it claims (i.e. accurate description of the world). This is good.

"Malo" is fine
Saturday, August 30th, 2025, 1:56 PM20 days ago

Which troll would most likely be high af watching troll Alphablocks marathons?

Don't ask why Geno hates Jade Harley.


Marth and Lyn from Fire Emblem in Super Smash Bros Ultimate


Lyndis
Saturday, August 30th, 2025, 3:02 PM19 days ago

Gamzee for the easy answer. Sollux for a option that feels more right



Sunday, August 31st, 2025, 2:00 PM19 days ago

What if troll blood had a fruity flavor?

Don't ask why Geno hates Jade Harley.


Marth and Lyn from Fire Emblem in Super Smash Bros Ultimate


Lyndis
Sunday, August 31st, 2025, 2:11 PM19 days ago

Just imagine how the presumably extant rainbow drinkers on Earth C feel upon drinking troll blood for the first time and tasting orange juice.


The image from that Tumblr post of a fox in the snow flinching from strong winds, captioned with "IT FUCKEN WIMDY", with the fox edited to have the god tier outfit of a Bard of Breath.


passeriInformal
Monday, September 1st, 2025, 2:05 PM18 days ago

What if baby trolls looked like human trolls?

Don't ask why Geno hates Jade Harley.


Marth and Lyn from Fire Emblem in Super Smash Bros Ultimate


Lyndis
Tuesday, September 2nd, 2025, 1:50 PM17 days ago

Would Gamzee collect all Faygo flavors?

And for trolls on the previous question, I mean human babies.

Don't ask why Geno hates Jade Harley.


Marth and Lyn from Fire Emblem in Super Smash Bros Ultimate


Lyndis
Tuesday, September 2nd, 2025, 1:54 PM17 days ago

Baby question:
I think trolls as a whole would be lot less "buggy" if that makes sense? The bugness is a important part of trolls imho and the grubs play into that a lot.


Faygo question:

He tried. Didnt finish it before sgrub happened and got really bummed. Its a shame he seemingly didnt get into alchemy, he couldve made 10000000 new faygo flavors to enjoy to his bloodpushers content



Tuesday, September 2nd, 2025, 11:38 PM16 days ago

I don't think Gamzee would be colleting them consciously but has definitely had all of them over the course of his life


as for the baby question...I thought at first this meant they'd also have the same skin and proportions as the baby humans (so no horns) and was going to say that troll/human fankids would be a bit different with the parents unable to tell what species their kid is until the horns grow in (or don't! lol); also I'd be curious how it would be handled in candy

but I guess you probably meant that they'd look like grey little babies with small horns? which would be really cute. I think there'd be a troll boss baby


^by tushyfatnocap on picmix (//y▽ ̄)╭

black_pine
Wednesday, September 3rd, 2025, 0:15 AM16 days ago

There are some rare-ass Faygo products. Some of those ones in glass bottles are basically impossible to come by reasonably. I don't think Gamzee would care enough. The main reason Faygo is a staple of juggalo culture is due to it being a bargin soda brand that's easy to get regardless of your financial situation.

slothArmy
Wednesday, September 3rd, 2025, 2:14 PM16 days ago

What if Eridan wasn’t a hateful jerk?

Don't ask why Geno hates Jade Harley.


Marth and Lyn from Fire Emblem in Super Smash Bros Ultimate


Lyndis
Wednesday, September 3rd, 2025, 2:26 PM16 days ago

he would still be a somewhat lame hipster...but his friendships might have thrived a bit more! Although I wonder if he wouldn't just start petty arguments, just without the bigotry


^by tushyfatnocap on picmix (//y▽ ̄)╭

black_pine
Thursday, September 4th, 2025, 2:05 PM15 days ago

What if Alternia wasn’t authoritarian?

Don't ask why Geno hates Jade Harley.


Marth and Lyn from Fire Emblem in Super Smash Bros Ultimate


Lyndis
Thursday, September 4th, 2025, 8:26 PM14 days ago

Before I offer my personal answer to that question, let me preface this by saying that I personally think a non-authoritarian Alternia seems to run counter to the trolls' very biology. Sure, the hemospectrum may be a lot more nuanced than real-world examples, but there is a clear hive-caste-system in their physiology; plentiful but low-ranking workers juxtaposed with fewer but longer-living upper classes. There is a fundamental inequality there that I think will be difficult for any troll society to truly counteract- especially since the differing lifespans, and therefore the amount of time each troll has to spend to advance their personal cause, is arguably the single biggest inequality between them!

I think it's telling that part of why Repiton in Vast Error falls under a very different governmental system than mainstream Alternia probably comes down to the simple fact that the degradation their planet and species is being confronted with has most likely leveled the playing field between the highbloods and the low from a pure-longevity standpoint. I've no clue how their take on the trolls differs from the 'main' batch of trolls beyond the things we can clearly tie into these past woes, mind you, but that feels like a significant contributing factor to me.


So what would non-authoritarian Alternia look like? Hard to say. We can't look to Beforus as an example here because- putting aside just how little we truly know about that setting- it is also authoritarian, even if Beforan!Feferi has a very different idea of what that means compared to the dystopic empire Her Imperious Condescension fostered. However, the fact that Gl'bgolyb is presumably not present in Beforus implies that such a sea monster is not necessary to propping up this imperial structure; the big sea monster was merely a tool to prevent anyone from interfering with The Condesce's Doc's designs.

In the event that the Sufferer, Summoner, or really any upstanding rebel succeeded in deposing the empire- or even just the trolls on Earth C learn from the mistakes of the past and strive to build a much more egalitarian system? I think that some fundamental sense of inequality will still remain in the low and highbloods, psychics and psionic powers aside. The traditional caste roles will probably get dismantled though; legislation will cease being a solely Tealblood thing, the Purplebloods are no longer forced to adhere to the Subjuggulator cult, etc., with only the chosen/volunteering Auxilliatrixes among the Jadebloods remaining true to their chosen role due to it being a fundamental part of their caste biology.

Governmental reform is not a quick or easy process, and there will be challenges- not just here but with population concerns, in providing equal opportunity between lowbloods and high, in properly reconciling the differences between all these castes and making each one feel heard and welcomed in the new, and likely many others that don't immediately come to mind. The only thing I can say for sure is this: that a non-authoritarian Alternia will be, by necessity, extremely different to the one we're acquainted with.

Oh no, not this dumb scepter again!

The Celesticane
Thursday, September 4th, 2025, 9:11 PM14 days ago

we don't really get much insight into the daily life of the troll kingdom on earth c but I imagine it would be quite similar. They all work together or at least didn't fall into their hierarchy again. Even with their different blood it seems as if they all just live like the people from the other kingdoms? So a non-authoritarian Alternia would just be quite normal...though I do wonder if the difference in life spans would result in certain blood types being overrepresented in different work fields? Like seadwellers working the archives/becoming historians since they live the longest


^by tushyfatnocap on picmix (//y▽ ̄)╭

black_pine
Friday, September 5th, 2025, 2:06 PM14 days ago

Would Jade lick Karkat’s feet like a dog?

Don't ask why Geno hates Jade Harley.


Marth and Lyn from Fire Emblem in Super Smash Bros Ultimate


Lyndis
Topic: Homestuck Questions of the Day