Candy for me.
I feel Meat kind of got hampered by having relatively little actual plot in Act 1 due to that story being already quite well-advanced by the end of the Epilogues. Some neat scenes, but most of them have fun dialogue without really changing anything. Meanwhile, Candy had a ton of trailing plot-threads that needed sorting out. It just had more drama.
(Am I the only one who wishes they had some kind of visual clue on-screen to show which timeline we're in?)
"This is StuckUnderHell, nor am I out of it." - Mephistopheles