In topic:Plurality (& Homestuck) Ask Anything Thread

Thursday, November 5th, 2026, 2:11 AM — 17 days ago· edited 17 days ago

Loading reply snippet...Pink Deltarune is deeply interesting to me on many levels.

Somehow, Toby keeps writing great ass queer rep. I dont know how he does it.

[for simplicity sake: ill call the grey one Maddie, the pink one Mewmew, and the system as a whole Pink]



A lot can be said about their plurality, but one of the most interesting ones representation-wise is how Maddie is the more "real" one. Maddie is the lightner, Maddie is the one who talks coherent sentences, etc. Meanwhile Mewmew is a fictional character, a darkner, talks mostly pre-recorded lines from the doll. But also they are still both important to eachother in a way that feels, uniquely plural to me. It's difficult to have this talk without a large multiparagraph talk about darkners and how they are treated in relation to lightners, but I trust you Apple Girlington #1 Fan to know all that already.

Maddie feels uniquely like the host (term used in plural systems to mean like, the main headmate, the one that fronts the most and is the "default") of the system, with Mewmew being the fictive headmate that helps her be emotionally stable and have the energy and will to go by the day. They are literally the "I imagine Naruto telling me to brush my teeth" type of dynamic and its kinda wonderful? Its a very personal and rarely talked about type of plurality, but these types of dynamics do exist (obviously not as exaggerated as Pink or Dentist Naruto, even tho they do exist out there); a lot of systems have hosts and a lot of systems also have headmates similar to Mewmew. And both are important for Pink the system as a whole to be happy; one part just cannot exist without the other.


Its part of why I spent so much on my last reply about understanding the system as a whole: Mewmew is a nonsequitor machine and has no real character of her own. Maddie is an annoyable girl with anger issues and is an Undertale D-lister (lets be honest, mad dummy was not on the level of Alphys or Papyrus, and even with the Switch fight vs her on the Mew Mew body didnt move the needle that much).


Together, tho?

Mewmew gives comedic relief and levity to Maddie, calming her down and providing a way to have Pink be a silly girl sometimes.

Maddie grounds Mewmew, giving them real characterization meat and allowing more in-depth relationships like their sisterhood with Orange to bloom.


Pink without Maddie is a nonsequitor non-character

Pink without Mewmew is a hateful, spiteful shut-in that nobody likes.

Together, they're a complex character that wants to be silly but has anger issues, that has a soft side and a harsh side, that can be funny but also knows when to lock in.

[Ironically, "has a soft side and a harsh side" refers both to Maddie - its Maddie that is harsh, but also its Maddie that is soft to Orange too. Mewmew helps other people enter Maddie's life and reach her soft core; together they're a tsundere, but it works out for Pink because Mewmew is a way to let others in on the soft core at Maddie's heart]


I dont think Pink would be a better character if it were Papyrus and Alphys in a trenchcoat.

She works so well because they are teammates, they compliment eachother, they are polar opposites but in a meaningful way rather than in a "this one is the yin and has a white color scheme and this one is the yang and has a black color scheme" way. And they both still have throughlines - they both have the same catgirl design, they both care about Orange, and they both are passionated about Kissy Mew Mew Cutie, altho in very different ways (one being a fan and the other a fictive of it).


Pink feels like a real system you could meet, an angerable person that copes with her harsh tendencies by being a big softie that invites people in and warns others that sometimes she gets grumpy but that they do still care deep down. Its cohesive, its understandable, its a sensical coping mechanism. It all checks out.

Check out my Balatro mod, Balatrostuck - LINKLINK

Also check out my Homestuck TTRPG, too! - LINKLINK

Fazzie
Fazzie
@fazzie
bus/bus
22 years old