In topic:Derse, Prospit, and Colonialism

Thursday, November 5th, 2026, 1:43 AM — 11 days ago

ok seriously though ha ha.


I like your observation that Prospit seeks, through its policy of "life" and expansion, to ultimately annihilate the Battlefield just as badly as Derse seeks to annihilate it. I think there's an obvious nuance to this in the fact that, despite being a nominally passive entity, Skaia still tries to protect itself from meteors in a way that it doesn't try to protect itself from inseminating tadpoles; the creation of new universes is, in its own way, the perpetuation of Skaia, because it means more sessions through which Skaia can propagate instances of itself. I might also argue that, even with the Battlefield's destruction, Skaia itself isn't necessarily destroyed in the birth of the Genesis Frog; it just changes form, right, from vapor to liquid water?* (hey, there's rain as birth imagery rearing its head in another unexpected place.) But to this same end, I think you're on the money that the Prospitians don't really care about Skaia as an entity to its own; it's just a step in a cosmic life cycle to them, something they seek to use by way of impregnation, and its destruction happens to be inconvenient to their intended use for it. And I think you're right that there are colonialist undertones to this, as well. The Battlefield is a fertile terra nullius in the most literal terms; it's a neutral "no man's land" whose sole purpose is to be fought over by rival imperial powers.


It's absolutely also true that Homestuck is interested in the juxtaposition between the passive, liberal empire and the warmongering fascist one; one could argue that Derse must always trump Prospit for basically the same reason that Alternians are cut out for winning Sburb and humans kind of aren't. The system that does nothing but expand is vulnerable to predators. But I think there are nuances to this too. The comic will absolutely play the 'liberal bureaucracy where nothing ever gets done' card on Derse where it suits; the reason Jack is so mad all the time is in no small part due to the fact that his real job is as a permission-slip-signing pen-pusher, their notorious authority regulators are in actuality bumbling boobs when it comes to handling weapons and their only real qualification are pasting parking violation tickets on crumpled wrecks... indeed, what comes to my mind when the subject of Cosy Colonialism on the Battlefield is broached is actually a Dersite:


You develop westward, settling those fertile plains and claiming them for your city.

You section off a number of RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL ZONES for civic growth, arranged in the only logical pattern that occurs to you.


I suppose one might argue that the Mayor's philosophy is meant to be counter to the mainstream of Dersite politics... but I wonder if the bit about his livestock teeth (to which Andrew's commentary suggests it might "make sense for the more populous classes, soldiers, workers, farmers, to be herbivorous, while the higher-ups are carnivorous") should be taken as suggesting that the lines between passive expansion and bloodthirsty predation are drawn along economic lines rather than racial-national ones, as it were. The Mayor's anti-monarchist stance, after all, is just as anti-Prospit as it is anti-Derse. Sorry for using your thread as an opportunity to reaffirm my beliefs that the kingdoms of Prospit and Derse are more similar than they are different lol? that said it is patently still true that free agents of Derse have a tendency for backstabbing and cheating that gives them an advantage over their Prospitian counterparts. it is hard to imagine there are lots of Prospitians running around with shark teeth too. but maybe that's racist of me to assume? I would like to see them.


The characterisation of Rose's underling torture in particular as cruel colonialist warfare is I suspect also a little off-base. While the comic gradually leads us to think of the underlings as people in much the same way consorts are, they are still within Sburb's political superstructure a colonising force of their own - the direct result of Derse commissioning the denizens to drastically alter (through pollution or otherwise) the land they live on. Which is not to say that Rose is a radical anti-colonial guerrilla fighter, but she has a tendency to accidentally fall on the right side of terrorism out of sheer love of the game.


Bringing this to the topic of Australia, too, I don't know how effectively we can link colonial attitudes to lunar dreaming when Derse dreamer Equius is seemingly the one interested in keeping Australia as-is rather than building on it.


*This borders on a plot hole to me btw. The way it's described to us, Skaia and the Battlefield are distinct entities; the Battlefield is a largely inert chunk of rock upon which the actual combat takes place, while Skaia is the cosmic intelligence and power that they're really fighting over. As you imply, when the Genesis Frog grows it seemingly bursts out of and destroys the Battlefield - but as I've pointed out, the shell of Skaia remains intact, if transformed. So is there any reason to believe meteors destroying the Battlefield wouldn't have the same effect...? like, you can't exactly blow up clouds with meteors. They're much more effective at blowing up the chunk of rock floating beneath the clouds. I guess we might speculate that Skaia needs something inside it, like, gravitationally speaking, to keep from dissipating, but...? Your explanation that the Battlefield itself is symbolically fertile ground goes part of the way to clearing this up, I think, but then it's still Skaia that's always being described as "a dormant crucible of unlimited creative potential" so what da hell.

>eats somewhere other than olive garden once

>fucking dies

JakeMorph
JakeMorph
@jakemorph
she/he/they
26 years old