I don't think it's unlikely, personally, I just think Gio badly reported on it. Like I've been in the MSPFA Homestuck channel for a while and people are just ripping apart their words. If anyone else speaks up or Gio elaborates on certain issues I'll understand.

Sarah Z seems to have backed up Gio as well, if it helps the case at all: https://bsky.app/profile/sarahz.bsky.social/post/3lvvpkibr6c22