this is a sort-of-theory built repeatedly on itself so i wouldnt be surprised if 1 little turn of canon collapses it but i have reason to believe nymphs are an all female race and satyrs are all male ( weird gender shit in hsbc + mythological origin + an actual honest to god Homosexual species since lets be real we did not get a full payoff with the leprechauns ) and i think another point in its favour is , assuming tc is a satyr and cc / aa are nymphs , nymphs have Witch Hats and satyrs have Wizard Hats on naglink . given rose wrote homestucks hp the ' witches are girls wizards are boys ' logic isnt entirely implausible to me . again im fully aware this will very easily be dislodged because of how many other theories it is building off of but it just means that now im a real homestuck fan